1,000 pages nobody wrote
3 min read
At its peak, QuickStaging's sitemap listed well over a thousand URLs, and I'd written almost none of them by hand. Google wasn't impressed, and in the end I took most of them back out of the sitemap.
The templates
The generated pages came in three families. The biggest was room × style: seven room types times fourteen furniture styles, so "Scandinavian living room", "industrial bedroom" and so on. That's 98 pages, or 882 URLs across nine languages.
Then there were 74 city pages. I wrote one of them by hand, and the rest came from a seed list with real market data for each city: average price, median days on market, neighbourhoods, a seller checklist. The last family was alternatives pages, one per competitor, thirteen in all.
On top of that sat the free tools, each with its own page. A flyer maker, a listing description generator, a photo checker and more, twenty-plus in total.
What Google did with them
Search Console was not kind. At one point about 913 URLs were "crawled, currently not indexed". Here's where three months of clicks came from:
| Page type | Clicks |
|---|---|
| 13 tool pages | 108 |
| Home page | 36 |
| 18 city pages | 1 |
| 16 alternatives pages | 0 |
| Blog | 2 |
| Room × style matrix | 0 (39 impressions) |
The tool pages got more clicks than everything else put together. The room × style matrix, by far the biggest family, got none.
It made sense once I measured it. Any two room × style pages were 93.6% identical. Swapping "bedroom" for "living room" and "Scandinavian" for "industrial" doesn't make a new page, and Google didn't treat it as one.
The cleanup
So I did the opposite of what programmatic SEO usually means, and shrank the site:
- Only English goes in the sitemap now. The other eight languages still exist; I just don't submit them.
- Room × style pages are
noindex, follow. They're still there for visitors and still pass links. They just stopped asking to be ranked. - Thin one-off pages came out of the sitemap.
That took the sitemap from over a thousand URLs to under two hundred. Over the following weeks the average position went from the high 40s to the low 20s, and tool pages now bring in about 57% of clicks. The image enhancer had 66 on its own. The grass-greener tool ranks around position 9.
Why tools win
Someone searching "make grass greener in listing photo" wants to upload a photo, not read about it. A tool page lets them do that, and a template page can't. Because they get to try it before signing up, the tool brings in users too, where a template page only brings visitors. Free tools accounted for 52 of 230 sign-ups.
Not every tool works, though. The flyer maker had 531 views and one download, because downloading needs an account. A tool that asks for something before it gives anything back is just a landing page with extra steps.
What I'd do differently
Next time I'd start with tools instead of templates. Build one page that does something useful, see if it ranks, then build the next one. I'd only generate pages where each one carries data the others don't, the way the city pages do. And I'd measure how alike the templates are before publishing 882 of them.